UBC economist Ross Hickey, right, was the keynote speaker at the Urban Development Institute luncheon held Thursday in Kelowna at the Coast Capri Hotel. Photo: Barry Gerding/Black Press

ALR an option for affordable housing development

UBC economist offers alternatives to speculation tax

A possible solution to create more affordable housing in Kelowna lies within the Agricultural Land Reserve, says a UBC economics professor.

Ross Hickey says development encroachment within the ALR and relaxing Development Cost Charges on housing projects until after the profits have been realized are admittedly “out of the box thinking” solutions.

“But the question here is do we really want to find a solution to the housing situation in Kelowna or not?” asked Hickey.

Related: Return to single-tier ALR

He was the keynote speaker at the Okanagan chapter of the Urban Development Institute luncheon Thursday at the Coast Capri Hotel.

Hickey said the ALR actually restrains development and drives up land prices.

“Do the impoverished in the community really benefit from urban apples?” he asked. “I’m sure there are developers who drive around Kelowna and look at ALR properties and think, ‘Gee, I could make something there?’”

Hickey acknowledged the “yes in my backyard” philosophy to living next to ALR land would have to be addressed, and that someone living sleeping their car can’t get a movement organized to support a development proposal in the same way a neighbourhood of residents can form a coalition to oppose it.

“I feel if you appeal to people’s sensibilities and how you are doing a good thing for others, people would respond more positively,” he said of the ALR option, which one UDI member described as “somewhat out there” as a solution.

Asked if allowing development on Crown land is another alternative, Hickey said he hasn’t looked at that option in detail, but suggested such lands generally tend to be on the periphery of a community while ALR land is more readily found close to an urban centre and amenity services such as transit.

“I would suggest that the ALR option, pardon the pun, offers lower hanging fruit,” he added.

Related: Letter—Value of ALR is in fertility of the land

Hickey said the provincial government’s speculation tax to address affordable housing is well intended but poorly thought out for potential unintended consequences, and offers a blanket solution for a diverse problem that requires community-specific alternatives.

He says out-of-town owners of empty homes can avoid the tax, ranging from .5 to two per cent depending where you reside, by renting out their properties for a minimum of six months a year, the theory being that will help generate more rental market options.

But he says it could also drive down housing development in Kelowna, while satellite communities like Peachland or Lake Country, where the tax would not be applied, will generate more interest.

That, he says, creates a situation in Kelowna where development is being driven away from the area where people want to live and be near the urbanized services the city can provide and newcomers moving here seek out.

“The reality is we don’t really know what will happen if the speculation tax comes into being,” Hickey said. “We could end up seeing the cost for housing go up and the quantity of supply go down where that tax is being applied.”

Related: Proposed speculation tax already doing damage to West Kelowna

He said bad taxation policy can have an enduring negative affect, citing the window tax adopted in European countries during the 18th century to generate tax revenue.

“So what people did is fill in their windows to avoid the tax. When I was in Europe I kept noticing what looked like window openings at one time covered over by concrete and thought that was strange. I eventually realized that concrete covering was a long-lasting legacy of bad policy,” he said.

“I would disgree with finance minister Carole James that land speculation is necessarily a bad thing. It helps bring efficiency to the housing market.”

To report a typo, email: edit@kelownacapnews.com.


@BarryGerding
barry.gerding@blackpress.ca

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Stories Beneath the Surface exhibition now open at Revelstoke Museum

Revelstoke Museum and Archives opened a new exhibition on Oct. 18, 2018… Continue reading

Live results for the Revelstoke municipal election

Watch here and on Facebook for live results

A lifetime in education

Revelstoke’s Jeff Nicholson is retiring after 28 years

Revelstoke Grizzlies win 11th straight game

The Forum was packed on Saturday night

Preliminary inquiry for Sagmoen begins in Vernon

Sagmoen, whose charges were split into three separate matters, has been in custody since Oct. 2017

Revelstoke Cribs: Eagle Pass Lodge

Explore the eclectic houses, lodges and other spaces in and around Revelstoke… Continue reading

Interior Health urges public to get a flu shot

Health authority says it will help to stop the spread of influenza

Liberals write off $6.3 billion in loans as part of money never to be collected

That includes student loans and a $2.6 billion write off that came through Export Development Canada

Category 5 Hurricane Willa threatens Mexico’s Pacific coast

Hurricane-force winds extended 30 miles (45 kilometres) from the storm’s centre

Trudeau, McKenna to announce compensation for federal carbon plan

Provinces that don’t have a carbon price of at least $20 per tonne of emissions will have Ottawa’s plan forced on them

UPDATE: American rapper killed in skydiving accident

Man, 34, dies in skydiving accident Saturday near Westwold, between Vernon and Kelowna

Man who died at BC Ferries terminal shot himself as police fired: watchdog

Officers didn’t commit any offence, says police watchdog office

Voter turnout at 36% in B.C.’s municipal election

Vancouver saw 39% turnout, Surrey saw 33%

Harry and Meghan travel in different style on Australia tour

Prince Harry and his wife Meghan are on day seven of their 16-day tour of Australia and the South Pacific.

Most Read