Liability found in 2010 fatal Highway 1 accident

The accident occurred east of Revelstoke early in the morning

A trucking company was found liable on April 8, 2019 in B.C.’s Supreme Court for a 2010 fatal accident near Revelstoke. (File photo)

A trucking company has been found liable in a 2010 fatal accident on Highway 1 east of Revelstoke.

The file was brought to court when Taiko Carriers sued Highland Transport claiming damages for losses incurred as a result of the accident. Highland Transport counter-sued and Harley Biermann, the surviving driver, also sued Taiko Carriers.

All three actions were brought before one judge in B.C.’s Supreme Court to determine who was responsible for the accident.

“In my view, it is unfortunate that there has been such a delay in bringing this matter to trial,” said Justice Janet Winteringham, in her Reasons for Judgment.

On Feb. 3, 2010, at around 1:40 a.m., Mihail Atanasov was driving a Taiko Carriers transport truck eastbound on Highway 1 east of Revelstoke when he collided with a Highland Transport truck driven by Harley Biermann.

Atanasov and his passenger died in the accident.

The lawsuits were commenced two years after the accident and the judgment came down on April 8, 2019 in Vancouver.

READ MORE: Traffic up on Highway 1 but accidents down

Winteringham heard from both Biermann as well as Jarret Petrar, another truck driver, who did not witness the accident but did encounter the Taiko truck on the highway that night.

Berimann has been a truck driver for over 45 years and at the time had been driving the Calgary to Vancouver route every other night for three months.

Taiko’s representative suggested that Beirmann’s truck was in a jack-knife position at the time of the accident, which was plausible given the snowy and wet conditions on the highway that night. The company had hired Timothy Leggett, a professional engineer, to reconstruct the accident. He determined that the collision was a t-bone style impact.

However, Highland Transport also hired an engineer, James Hrycay, to reconstruct the accident, who came to another conclusion.

“Impact was neither a shallow angle side-swipe nor a 90-degree t-bone impact, but at some intermediate angle between those values,” Hrycay said in his analysis of the accident.

Beirmann denied that his trailer was jack-knifing at the time of the accident saying that it was “exactly where it was supposed to be”.

He was accused of using his trailer brakes that night, potentially causing his truck to jack-knife given the slippery conditions.

During cross-examination the judge noted that Beirmann seemed “genuinely surprised, during his cross-examination, with the suggestion that he would have used his trailer brakes in the circumstances presented.”

READ MORE: Widow’s petition demans mandatory training for truckers

Petrar, another driver on the highway in the area that night, testified that the Taiko driver was driving erratically before the accident, especially given the conditions. He described the driver’s several attempts to pass both Petrar and another vehicle on the highway, pulling out and then slowing down and pulling back behind a few times before succeeding.

As well as witnesses and testimony from the RCMP officer who first arrived on the scene, the judge heard reports from both engineers as well as cross-examinations.

“I have found that Leggett’s theory, as explained by him, was flawed because it drove an analysis with a starting point that was inconsistent with the evidence tendered during the trial and with the findings of fact I make,” Winteringham said.

Winteringham agreed that Biermann’s truck was not in a jack-knife position and that the driver of the Taiko truck drove across the centre-line and was 100 per cent at fault for the accident.

“If the parties are unable to agree on costs, they may speak to the issue,” Winteringham said.


 

@JDoll_Revy
jocelyn.doll@revelstokereview.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Just Posted

Kootenay-Columbia MP talks throne speech, USMCA trade deal

Rob Morrison to open constituency office in Cranbrook at 800C Baker St. on Dec. 19

Kootenay-Columbia MP reacts to leader’s surprise resignation

The resignation of Conservative Party leader Andrew Scheer caught members of his caucus by surprise

Graduation rates in Revelstoke 11 per cent above provincial average

Provincial average for high school graduation is 81 per cent, while it’s 92 per cent in Revelstoke

Cycling association and snowmobile club receive RMI funding

Revelstoke City Council delayed approving their applications earlier this year

Big Eddy School lots sold for $1.6 million

The Revelstoke school board approved the sales yesterday

‘Not a decision I came to lightly:’ Scheer to resign as Conservative leader

Decision comes after weeks of Conservative infighting following the October election

Race to replace Andrew Scheer could be a crowded one

Many familiar faces, such as Maxime Bernier, Jason Kenney, Doug Ford and Kevin O’Leary, have said no

North Okanagan-Shuswap MP surprised by Conservative leader’s resignation

Arnold predicts Conservative party will remain united in its quest to become government

Vernon business evacuated after gas line hit

A natural gas line was struck, emergency responders unsure of size

Lug nuts loosened on several vehicles in Vernon

Mischief makers reportedly compromising cars; motorists reminded to check vehicles before operating

Vernon nurse pleads guilty to arson

Guilty pleas related to 2016 arson

Safe donation bins coming to Okanagan streets

UBC Okanagan engineering students help design bins for non-profits

Former Summerland lifeguard will continue to receive pension benefits

Edward Casavant has pleaded guilty to several child sexual assault and pornography charges

B.C. SPCA seizes dogs chained up outside among scrap metal, garbage

Shepherd-breed dogs were living in ‘deplorable conditions.’

Most Read