This picture shows the building in its relation to the nearby avalanche path.

Did an avalanche take out the old water bottling plant?

The old Revelstoke Water Bottling Plant collapsed earlier this month. Was it taken out by the snow load on the roof or an avalanche?



The old Revelstoke Water Bottling Plant near Albert Canyon collapsed earlier this month – done in by this winter’s snow. Though how exactly it came down is a question mark.

“It was an avalanche,” said Merv Krywa of Revelstoke Property Management, who inspected the building after it collapsed.

“That was not the case,” said Sylvain Hebert of Storm Mountain Technical Services, the contractor who does avalanche control for CP Rail.

The bottling plant came down sometime before March 10. It was closed down in September 2009 and has been empty since then.

When the I first heard about it, I thought it would make for a good picture and that’s about it. When I was told it was knocked down by an avalanche, I couldn’t believe it. I couldn’t imagine they would have built a factory where people worked for close to 20 years in an avalanche path – even an infrequent one.

I took a look at Google Earth and sure enough there is an avalanche path that comes down several hundred metres from the plant, on the other side of the Illecillewaet River.

I was given some pictures of the site that showed twisted metal beams and flattened walls mixed in with lots of snow. Some of the pictures showed the slide path but there was no overarching picture showing the whole area, making it difficult to make an assessment. Unfortunately, road closures and other commitments prevented me from visiting the site myself so I asked around and eventually ended up talking to Jim Bay, the manager of AvaTerra, which used to do the avalanche control work for the railway.

“There’s no question a slide could affect that plant,” he told me. “The plant has been affected in the past. There has been some very heavy dust plastering from avalanches all over the plant.”

He said that when he did control work for the railway, he questioned doing avalanche control on that slide path because of the potential to impact the plant.

“It’s definitely in range of a slide path – a one-in-every-75-year return period, that’s the calculated thing,” Bay said. “It’s possible given the recent avalanche activity that we had and it would be very interesting for someone to take a look at it.”

He then told me to call Hebert. When we spoke, Hebert said he had been to the area recently and that the nearby avalanche path had slid, but it came down several hundred metres away.

“That’s why I say with confidence that it was not an avalanche that collapsed the building, although I can’t say for sure because I wasn’t there when the avalanche ran,” he said.

The slide that came down was a wet one, he told me, which was unlikely to produce enough of an air blast or powder cloud to take out the plant. “It leads me to believe that the building collapsed from the weight of the snow more than  from an air blast from an avalanche.”

As I said, I was unable to verify his assertion myself and Krywa insisted that an avalanche hit the building, adding it survived last year’s much heavier snow load.

Ice River Springs, which owns the building, is conducting an assessment of the site.

The company is reponsible for the clean-up and Cory Legebokow from the Ministry of the Environment said he had not been contacted about any environmental issues from the buildings collapse.

“I don’t suspect there’s any issue out there other than them losing their building,” he said.

The property is for sale.

 

Just Posted

Keep that ‘friendly small town’ feel in Revelstoke this Welcome Week

Make friends with your new neighbours at one of many fun events Nov. 23-30

Okanagan teenagers found after missing for four days

The pair, believed to be dating, had been missing since Nov. 15.

Revelstoke Climbers Access Society hosting night of climbing films

The fundraiser is on Nov. 22 at the Roxy Theatre

Free permit needed to collect firewood on crown land

Revelstoke residents reminded to apply for free permit

Investigation ongoing after shots fired in North Okanagan

RCMP have no updates from Nov. 1 incident

Penticton artist brings joy to others through her painting

Hedy Munawych is 96 years old and just loves painting the beauty of the world around her.

Kamloops woman sues Armstrong IPE for Slingshot mishap

Woman claims ride gone wrong caused injury, loss of wages and other damages

UPDATED: Vancouver Island’s Joe gets suspended sentence in Teddy the dog cruelty case

Melissa Tooshley expected in court on Thursday in same case

Alleged drunk driver survives crash into Kettle River

The crash happened Saturday near Grand Forks

Woman ‘horrified’ after being told to trek 200 kilometres home from Kamloops hospital

‘I can’t get from Kamloops back to 100 Mile House injured, confused… no shoes, no clothes whatsoever’

Sentencing scheduled Tuesday for man who killed Belgian tourist

Sean McKenzie pleaded guilty to second-degree murder of 28-year-old Amelie Sakkalis near Boston Bar

Canadian universities encourage exchange students in Hong Kong to head home

UBC said 11 of its 32 students completing programs in Hong Kong have already left

Most Read