Revelstoke council delays decision on highway intersection design

Mayor calls for special meeting on intersection. Consultant puts estimated cost at $2.1 million. Shell threatens legal action.

An image of the proposed layout for the highway intersection.

Revelstoke council pushed off a decision on the problematic Trans-Canada Highway intersection, citing fears over ballooning costs and worries the design won’t work.

A new report by McElhanney Consulting, the engineering firm hired to create a design for the new intersection and oversee its construction, estimates the cost of fixing the intersection at $2.1 million, and it also contains letters of opposition from affected businesses.

That had council call for a special meeting to discuss the intersection. It has been scheduled for Wednesday, May 4, at 3 p.m.

“I’m still not confident about this whole situation and where we’re going with it and what we’re doing,” said councillor Connie Brothers during Tuesday’s council meeting. I just want to make sure w’ere not putting a Band-Aid on something for that amount of money rather than dealing with the problem fully.”

The proposed design blocks left turns from Victoria Road to the Shell station, and from the Woodenhead Loop to Victoria Road. A roundabout would be built at Victoria Road and Wright Street to route traffic flow.

The final design makes minor changes to the plans presented at an open house in March. Notably, it modifies the access to the frontage road that passes the Shell Station, and improves pedestrian access to the Shell. It also scraps the proposed roundabout at Laforme Boulevard and Fraser Drive.

Significantly, McElhanney estimates the cost of the project at $2.1 million, far more than the $1.2 million the city has budgeted the work in its 2016–20 financial plan.

The city plans to use Development Cost Charge funds to pay for the work, but Graham Inglis, the city’s director of finance, said there’s only about $1 million in the DCC fund directed to the work.

A report by McLehanney says the proposed intersection would improve peak traffic flows to a rating of B, from a rating of E. A rating of A indicates free flowing traffic, while an F means gridlock.

The report addresses concerns raised at an open house held in March about snow removal and the ability of big trucks to navigate the Wright Street roundabout.

Council was split on whether or not to proceed on the revised design. Linda Nixon voted in favour of moving forward.

“I think we can not put off moving those people from Columbia Park back and forth safely to their neighbourhood,” she said. “I am concerned that if we do not take this forward today, then we are looking at next year before we come up with a solution.”

Mayor Mark McKee said he wasn’t “100 per cent happy” with the plan, especially with the potential $2.1 million price tag.

“I’m not going to vote in favour because I think we need a little bit more time and we need more massaging,” he said.

He proposed holding a special council meeting to discuss the proposal in more detail.

Mike Thomas, the city’s director of engineering, said he didn’t think the final cost would be as high as $2.1 million.

“I’d be really surprised if we went out to tender and received a price that high,” he said. “It doesn’t seem like $2.1 million worth of work.”

He warned that if council didn’t make a decision within the next month, it would be very difficult to finish the work by next summer. McElhanney recommends building the roundabout this year, with the work at Mutas Road to be completed in the spring of 2017.

Thomas said the city is looking for grant opportunities to help pay for the construction, and that it would be seeking a contribution from the Ministry of Transportation & Infrastructure.

The city had a gas tax grant application turned down.

In the end, McKee, Brothers, Sulz and English voted against approving the design, while Scott Duke, Nixon and Aaron Orlando voted for it.

One thing that’s not known at this point is how the changes address the concerns of existing businesses. The owners of Tim Hortons and Shell both submitted comments opposing the preliminary design, with Shell threatening legal action if it were to go through.

When asked about this, McKee responded: “I think that’s going to be part of council discussion on what it wants to do. I think we all have to realize that as a community, when you have a big problem like we have down there, to think you’re going to make 100 per cent of the people and businesses happy is going to be difficult.”

Thomas told the Review the city has not had follow-up meetings with Shell or Tim Hortons. “We haven’t gone back out to the stakeholders at this point. We want to bring these things to council first.”

 

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Chilliwack on the map for Salmon Arm Roots and Blues

Canadian music legends confirmed for 28th annual music festival

Volunteer spends hundreds of hours restoring piece of railway history

Revelstoke Railway Museum now home to an authentic Kalamazzo No. 2 Section Handcar

Awesome lineup of music this weekend in Revelstoke

See bands and DJs Thursday, Friday and Saturday

Revelstoke RCMP hand out 59 tickets during driving enforcement campaign

Between Jan. 16 and 19 they handed out 21 speeding relative to conditions tickets

Avalanche closure scheduled, more snow on the way

Roads and weather for Revelstoke Jan. 20

VIDEO: Soldiers trade rifles for snow shovels to help dig out St. John’s

A state of emergency is set to extend into a fifth day

Warm ‘blob’ could be behind mass starvation of North Pacific seabirds: study

Unprecedented death toll raises red flag for North American marine ecosystems

North Okanagan woman pleas for return of stolen scooter

‘It’s been another kick in the teeth… how do you get ahead and keep your head above water?’

Police search for owner of another icy sailboat on Okanagan Lake

The frozen vessel was spotted near the 800 block of Manhattan Drive in Kelowna

Future of Penticton francophone school secured following funding announcement

$11.5M in funding means École Entre-lacs now independently owned and operated

ICBC to bring in ranking system for collision, glass repair shops

Change comes after the much-maligned auto insurer has faced criticism for sky-high premiums

City of Vernon to redirect reclaimed water into Okanagan Lake

MacKay Reservoir nears capacity; city to reflow water into lake near Kin Beach

‘It was just so fast’: B.C. teen recalls 150-metre fall down Oregon mountain

Surrey’s Gurbaz Singh broke his leg on Mount Hood on Dec. 30

Most Read