Delays in Revelstoke court shows systemic problems

Problems in Revelstoke court lead to delayed justice, risk of charges getting thrown out.

Covering court in Revelstoke is a strange affair. It’s a mix of the mundane, the bizarre and, recently, the highly disturbing. Court takes place in Revelstoke the first Wednesday and Thursday of every month. Wednesday is for short matters – first appearances, arraignment hearings, applications, sentencings, and short small claims and family court matters.

It’s a hodge podge of cases that frequently get put off, sometimes come to a quick conclusion, and often leave the public at the back somewhat bewildered as to what’s going on. I’ve seen cases get adjourned for several months in a row, and sometimes a guilty plea is entered and everything is wrapped up in hours.

Most of the infractions seem to involve impaired driving, or driving without a license. Sometimes there’s violent assault or drug possession charges on the docket. Those I pay attention to and, depending on the circumstances, will write about in the newspaper. My general rule is to write about people who put the public at risk – whether its through a case of dangerous driving, violent assault, or higher-level drug dealing. Or it could something even more nefarious like the child pornography charges that are working their way through the system.

The court has a rhythm that I’ve gotten used to, but one thing that is clear is that the system has major issues. I recently covered the conclusion of one case that sat idle for several years after the defence lawyer retired just before closing remarks. I guess he didn’t think it was important to wrap up his business before enjoying the rest of his life.

This months court day seemed particularly interesting. First, the courtroom was cleared when the child pornography case started. It’s the first time that’s ever happened in my three years of covering Revelstoke court. The case was adjourned to next month.

Most interesting is Revelstoke’s newest judge, Mayland McKimm. McKimm was appointed a judge in early 2012 and started in Revelstoke in June. When he started, his manner in court was surprising. He could be very jocular, verging on innappropriate, when talking to an accused person. Fortunately, it seems he’s toned that down. How would you like to see a judge chortling when your future is at stake?

More significantly, he’s taken the court to task for the delays and backlogs that plague the system. He’s shown little tolerance for adjournments and he also shows interest in keeping the trial list clean.

One of the bigger issues in Revelstoke court is there’s often more trial time scheduled than there is time to hold a trial. Often, two or so days worth of trials can be scheduled for the one day of trial time Revelstoke is currently allotted.

This month really illustrated the problem. There were four cases set for trial confirmation hearings and each were set for a half-day trial on Thursday, Feb. 7. Obviously, those numbers don’t add up.

Further adding to the problem is the fact three of the trials had already been delayed once before. First up for trial confirmation was Matthew Murray Devlin, who was charged with impaired driving on Feb. 6, 2010. His first trial date in May 2011 was postponed when he failed to appear.

Then there was Michael Darrell Robinson, a serial offender who this time is facing assault charges. His trial was previously set for last September, but was delayed due to a clogged trial list that month.

The other delayed trial was Cameron Paul Thomson. His impaired trial was stopped in August after a mistrial was declared when the Crown prosecutor said she had a conflict with one of the witnesses.

Finally, there was Chad Lott – also facing an impaired charge – who’s trial was the only one to not yet be delayed, so he was the first scratched off February’s trial list.

Then it came down to deciding which two of the three trials should proceed. Robinson, being a case of assault, was put on the list because of the violent nature of the charges.

Devlin was also scheduled for February because his charges were already three years old. That meant Thomson’s trial was delayed once more, prompting his lawyer Melissa Klages to indicate she would seek to have it thrown out of court on account of insitutional delay.

The problem is Revelstoke just doesn’t have enough trial days. While often one day is enough (this month there were no trials on Thursday), there are many instances where one day just isn’t enough. In those cases, the court system needs to be able to allot a second day for trials when required.

This shouldn’t be too hard to do. Trials are scheduled months in advance so the administrators should be able to know when an extra day is needed and plan in advance. If circumstances (such as a guilty plea or stay before the trial) dictate that the trial get cancelled, then we’ll end up paying a judge to stay at home. Still, that’s better than the alternative of having someone dragged through the court system for years, or having a potential criminal get off because of problems with the system.

Of course, this would mean hiring more judges, which means more funding, something the B.C. government needs to provide, hopefully  with support from Ottawa withit’s “tough on crime” agenda.

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Molotov cocktails thrown at Revelstoke home in arson attempt

The flames were extinguished before they spread

Community Connections expand into new property

The Revelstoke social services organization continues to grow

Hunting cabins were built west of Summerland

Area around Darke Lake was once known as the Piggeries

PHOTOS: What summer 2020 is like in Revelstoke

Contributors submit their favourite photos from this summer

Celebrate wildflowers next week in Revelstoke

Tourism Revelstoke is hosting a wildflower festival with various activities Aug. 9-16

B.C. would not send students back to school if there was ‘overwhelming risk’: Horgan

Plan has left many parents across the province worried about their children’s safety

Community Foundation of South Okanagan Similkameen presents bursaries worth more than $40,000

Nine endowment funds provided bursaries to 20 students within region

Masks to be mandatory on BC Transit, TransLink starting Aug. 24

Both BC Transit and TransLink made the announcement in separate press releases on Thursday

British Columbians worried as end of COVID-19 rental supplement looms

Single mom struggles as supplement was her saving grace

Fire at Marble Point near Sicamous now under control

Two days of work on the fire has reduced its size and controlled it

Driver rescued after car goes down embankment near Kelowna

The Kelowna Fire Department performed the high-angle rope rescue around 7:10 p.m. on Aug. 5

UPDATE: Wildfire forces evacuation of homes Summerland and Penticton

Emergency vehicles are at the scene near Sage Mesa

Arson suspected in several wildfires lit near Kootenay town

RCMP making progress in arson investigation of Marsh Creek fires

Three screening officers at Vancouver airport test positive for COVID-19

The public is not believed to be at risk of exposure

Most Read